Scribe Summit Debate

The Scribe SUMMIT Disputation is an in-character scribe debate tournament for the Blue Caste, Gor-wide. Scribes face off in knockout rounds with one-on-one debates judged by a third party. There will be two rounds with a third final round on Sunday. 5000 L prize. It will be based on wits, knowledge of Gor  and a logical presentation.

See attached for more information ...

***-----------***----------***----------***----------***

WHAT IS THE SCRIBE SUMMIT DISPUTATION? 

Selnar, a few months ago had a public debate as a city. That event crafted by Cornelius Tarrant is the inspiration for this event.

Prize Money 5000 L 

"I have never been too clear as to the grounds on which the disputes of scribes are to be adjudicated, and it is not too infrequent that both disputants leave the field each fully convinced that he has had the best of the contest. In differences among members of my own caste, that of the Warriors, it is easier to tell who has carried the day, for the defeated one often lies wounded or slain at the victor's feet. In the contests of scribes, on the other hand, the blood that is spilled is invisible and the valiant foe men retire in good order, reviling their enemies and recouping their forces for the next day's campaign."

The Scribe SUMMIT Disputation is an in-character scribe debate tournament. Scribes face off in knockout rounds with one-on-one debates judged by a third party. There will be two rounds with a third final round on Sunday. 5000 L prize. Why should the warriors be the ones who get prizes. It will be based on wits, knowledge of Gor  and a logical presentation.

HOW DOES THE TOURNAMENT WORK?

Win your match, and you move on the final round on Sunday Sept 28th

WHAT'S THE TIME LINE?

Friday 12 PM First Debate

Saturday 10 am Second Debate 

Sunday 12 pm final round winners of 

HOW DO MATCHES GET SCHEDULED?

Each debate team consists of two debaters and one judge. If you are to debate on Friday or Saturday is determined by your schedules, but the two winners have to be available on Sunday for the final round.

WHAT'S THE FORMAT OF EACH DEBATE?

Each debate follows a six-post format:

1. Affirmative Argument (Debater 1)

2. Negative Argument (Debater 2)

3. Affirmative Rebuttal (Debater 1)

4. Negative Rebuttal (Debater 2)

5. Affirmative Closing (Debater 1)

6. Negative Closing (Debater 2)

Each debater has 10 minutes per post max can be shorter. A full debate takes roughly 60 minutes. usually is shorter

ARE THERE POST RULES?

Yes. Posts are capped at 250 words. Typically 150–200 words per post, in the interest of time. We want concise, high-quality exchanges, not essays. 

WHAT ARE THE DEBATES ABOUT?

Topics are legal, philosophical, or political in nature. Each match will have its own assigned prompt, which is kept short and clear. Debaters must argue from the perspective of Gorean logic and social context, not modern ideas.

CAN I USE AI TO HELP?

No. The spirit of the Disputation is authentic character writing and debate. You may prepare notes, but AI-generated content is not allowed. Judges and admins may disqualify debaters if AI use is suspected.

WHO CAN JOIN?

Any literate Gorean scribe role player is welcome to register, whether a member of SCoG or not. 

***-----------***----------***----------***----------***

SCRIBE SUMMIT DISPUTATION

Please fill out this form and send it to Abraham Jacobson  (abrahamJacobs2) via IM to register for the upcoming scribe debate tournament.

Character Name:

Avatar Name:

Home City / Sim:

Caste / Role:

Expression of Interest in Role (select one): Debator | Judge | 

either

Availability (Time Zone or preferred posting hours): 

Brief RP experience or relevant background (optional):

Do you understand and agree to the rules? Yes/No

yes

5 posts per round, max 200 words each

No AI-generated writing allowed

Commitment to active participation both IC and OOC

yes

Thank you for your interest! Looking forward to your participation. Please send this completed form back via IM.

***-----------***----------***----------***----------***

WHAT IF SOMEONE MISSES THEIR MATCH?

If a debater is unresponsive, the match may be forfeited. 

I WANT TO OBSERVE OR JUDGE, CAN I?

Yes! Observers are welcome, and we still seek a few volunteer judges. Contact Abraham Jacobson abrahamjacobs2 to join as a judge or observer or just to get help on any issue.